Same Inputs, Different Answers: 29 Savings Calculators Tested
The short answer
We entered the same savings scenarios into 29 public calculators in five markets on 21 November 2026. Identical inputs produced results up to 3.7% apart. Two conventions explain almost every difference: whether "7% a year" is divided by 12 or converted to the equivalent monthly rate, (1.07)^(1/12) − 1, and whether each deposit is made at the start or the end of the month. Neither choice is an error, but most calculators do not say which one they use.
Key findings
- India: a ₹5,000 monthly SIP at 12% for 10 years shows ₹11,61,695, ₹11,50,193 or ₹11,20,179 depending on the calculator, a ₹41,516 (3.7%) spread.
- Germany: 200 € a month at 7% for 25 years shows 157.494 € or 162.959,42 €, a 5.465 € (3.5%) spread for the same stated return.
- Japan: ¥30,000 a month at 3% for 20 years shows 9,805,633円, 9,828,976円 or 9,849,060円, a ¥43,427 (0.4%) spread; the regulator, Nomura and MUFG agree.
- United States and international: all seven tested calculators agree to the cent once deposit timing matches; timing alone moves the 30-year result by $3,558.
- Korea: all five calculators agree to the won, because installment-savings interest follows one standard formula.
- Two calculators label their rate input as an annual effective rate or APY while calculating with it as a nominal rate (Bankrate, Finanzfluss's monthly setting).
Why identical inputs differ
A savings calculator turns a yearly rate r into a monthly growth rate i. Dividing by 12 (i = r/12) treats r as a nominal rate compounded monthly; at 7% that is an effective 7.23% a year. Converting it, i = (1 + r)^(1/12) − 1, treats r as the actual yearly return, the way fund performance, CAGR and APY are quoted. Over 25 or 30 years the difference compounds to 3–4% of the final balance.
The second choice is timing. A deposit made at the start of each month earns one more month of growth than one made at the end, which adds a factor of (1 + i) to every deposit. Indian SIP calculators and German Sparplan calculators mostly invest at the start; most US calculators and the Japanese regulator's simulator assume the end.
i = r / 12 (nominal)
i = (1 + r)^(1/12) − 1 (equivalent monthly rate)
End of month: FV = P × ((1 + i)^n − 1) / i
Start of month: FV = P × ((1 + i)^n − 1) / i × (1 + i)United States and international
Scenario A: $10,000 plus $500 a month at 7% for 30 years, compounded monthly. Scenario B: $10,000 at 7% for 10 years, compounded daily. Every calculator that returned a result agreed to the cent once deposit timing matched: $691,150.47 with deposits at the end of each month and $694,708.72 at the start. Defaults differ: Omni Calculator starts with deposits at the beginning of the period, TheCalculatorSite at the end. Bankrate asks for the rate as an APY but its result equals 7% treated as a nominal rate compounded monthly. Moneysmart offers monthly or yearly compounding only, so its scenario B figure is a monthly result. Investor.gov refused automated access (HTTP 403) and was not tested.
| Calculator | Scenario and setting | Result shown | Matches |
|---|---|---|---|
| Investor.gov (SEC) | A | Not tested (blocked automated access) | — |
| Investor.gov (SEC) | B | Not tested (blocked automated access) | — |
| NerdWallet | A · Monthly | $691,150.47 | Rate ÷ 12, deposit at month end |
| NerdWallet | B · Daily | $20,136.18 | Daily compounding (365-day year) |
| Bankrate | A · Compound monthly | $691,150.47 | Rate ÷ 12, deposit at month end |
| Bankrate | B · Compound daily | $20,136.18 | Daily compounding (365-day year) |
| TheCalculatorSite | A · Deposits made at what point in period? Beginning | $694,708.72 | Rate ÷ 12, deposit at month start |
| TheCalculatorSite | A · Deposits made at what point in period? End | $691,150.47 | Rate ÷ 12, deposit at month end |
| TheCalculatorSite | B · Daily (365/yr) | $20,136.18 | Daily compounding (365-day year) |
| Omni Calculator | A · When? Beginning of period | $694,708.72 | Rate ÷ 12, deposit at month start |
| Omni Calculator | A · When? End of period | $691,150.47 | Rate ÷ 12, deposit at month end |
| Omni Calculator | B · Daily (365/Yr) | $20,136.18 | Daily compounding (365-day year) |
| Moneysmart (ASIC) | A · Monthly | $691,150 | Rate ÷ 12, deposit at month end |
| Moneysmart (ASIC) | B · Monthly | $20,097 | Monthly compounding (daily not offered) |
| Calculator.net | A · Contribute at the beginning of each compounding period | $694,708.72 | Rate ÷ 12, deposit at month start |
| Calculator.net | A · Contribute at the end of each compounding period | $691,150.47 | Rate ÷ 12, deposit at month end |
| Calculator.net | B · Contribute at the beginning of each compounding period | $20,136.18 | Daily compounding (365-day year) |
| Calculator.net | B · Contribute at the end of each compounding period | $20,136.18 | Daily compounding (365-day year) |
| Moneychimp | B · Make additions at start of each compounding period | $ 20,136.18 | Daily compounding (365-day year) |
| Moneychimp | B · Make additions at end of each compounding period | $ 20,136.18 | Daily compounding (365-day year) |
| Moneychimp | A · Make additions at start of each compounding period | $ 694,708.72 | Rate ÷ 12, deposit at month start |
| Moneychimp | A · Make additions at end of each compounding period | $ 691,150.47 | Rate ÷ 12, deposit at month end |
India (SIP)
Scenario C: a ₹5,000 monthly SIP at 12% a year for 10 years. Three conventions are in use. SBI Securities and Motilal Oswal divide 12% by 12 and invest at the start of the month (₹11,61,695). Groww, Franklin Templeton and ET Money use the equivalent monthly rate, (1.12)^(1/12) − 1, also at the start of the month (₹11,20,179). SEBI's investor-education calculator divides by 12 and invests at the end of the month (₹11.5 lakh, ₹11,50,193 unrounded). The gap between the highest and lowest is ₹41,516, or 3.7%, for identical inputs.
| Calculator | Scenario and setting | Result shown | Matches |
|---|---|---|---|
| Groww | C | ₹11,20,179 | Equivalent monthly rate, start of month |
| SEBI investor education | C | ₹11.5 Lacs | Rate ÷ 12, end of month |
| Motilal Oswal MF | C | ₹ 11,61,695 | Rate ÷ 12, start of month |
| Motilal Oswal MF | C2 | ₹ 16,87,163 | Rate ÷ 12, start of month |
| Franklin Templeton India | C | ₹11,20,179 | Equivalent monthly rate, start of month |
| ET Money | C | ₹11.2 Lacs | Equivalent monthly rate, start of month |
| SBI Securities | C | ₹11,61,695 | Rate ÷ 12, start of month |
| Groww | C2 | ₹16,34,449 | Equivalent monthly rate, start of month |
Japan (積立シミュレーション)
Scenario D: ¥30,000 a month at 3% a year for 20 years. The FSA's つみたてシミュレーター, Nomura and MUFG Asset Management agree on 9,805,633円 (the equivalent monthly rate, deposits at month end). Rakuten Securities shows 9,849,060円, which equals 3% ÷ 12 with month-end deposits. SBI Securities shows 9,828,976円, which matches no standard convention; it is 841円 below the equivalent-monthly-rate, start-of-month result.
| Calculator | Scenario and setting | Result shown | Matches |
|---|---|---|---|
| FSA つみたてシミュレーター | D | 981万円 | Equivalent monthly rate, end of month |
| SBI証券 | D | 9,828,976円 | Not a standard convention (closest: Equivalent monthly rate, start of month, off by -840.65) |
| 楽天証券 | D | 9,849,060円 | Rate ÷ 12, end of month |
| 野村證券 みらい電卓 | D | 積立結果は980.6万円になります。 | Equivalent monthly rate, end of month |
| 三菱UFJアセットマネジメント | D | 9,805,633円 | Equivalent monthly rate, end of month |
Korea (적금)
Scenario F: 300,000원 a month for 12 months at 3.0%, simple interest, 15.4% tax. All five calculators, from the savings-bank federation and four banks or platforms, agree on 3,649,491원 at maturity after tax, and on 3,649,948원 with monthly compounding (Finda shows 3,649,947원, a one-won truncation). Korea's installment-savings formula is standardised: interest = deposit × rate × n(n+1)/2 ÷ 12.
| Calculator | Scenario and setting | Result shown | Matches |
|---|---|---|---|
| 저축은행중앙회 | F | 일반세율(15.40%)가입시 3,649,491을 수령하시게 됩니다. | Simple interest per deposit (단리) |
| 제주은행 | F | 3,649,491 | Simple interest per deposit (단리) |
| 제주은행 | F2 | 3,649,948 | Monthly compounding (월복리) |
| KB국민은행 | F | 3,649,491원 | Simple interest per deposit (단리) |
| KB국민은행 | F2 | 3,649,948원 | Monthly compounding (월복리) |
| 우리은행 | F | 3,649,491 | Simple interest per deposit (단리) |
| 우리은행 | F2 | 3,649,948 | Monthly compounding (월복리) |
| 핀다 | F | 3,649,491원 | Simple interest per deposit (단리) |
| 핀다 | F2 | 3,649,947원 | Monthly compounding (월복리) |
Germany (Sparplan)
Scenario E: 200 € a month at 7% a year for 25 years, no costs or tax. Finanztip, Frankfurter Sparkasse and extraETF's default give 157.494 € (the equivalent monthly rate, payments at the start of the month). justETF, Invesco and Finanzfluss's monthly setting give 162.959,42 € (7% ÷ 12). That is a 5.465 € (3.5%) difference for the same stated return; Finanzfluss labels its input an effective annual rate (effektiver Jahreszins), yet its monthly setting treats it as nominal. extraETF's optional settings alone span 151.769,75 € to 162.959,42 €.
| Calculator | Scenario and setting | Result shown | Matches |
|---|---|---|---|
| Finanztip | E | 157.494 € | Equivalent monthly rate, start of month |
| justETF | E | 162.959,42 EUR | Rate ÷ 12, start of month |
| Finanzfluss | E · Zinsintervall: monatlich | 162.959,42€ | Rate ÷ 12, start of month |
| Finanzfluss | E · Zinsintervall: jährlich | 157.553,35€ | Interest credited yearly, simple interest within the year (start) |
| extraETF | E · Einzahlungsart: Vorschüssig; Zinsperiode: Monatlich; Renditeberechnung: Geometrische Rendite | 157.493,86 € | Equivalent monthly rate, start of month |
| extraETF | E · Einzahlungsart: Vorschüssig; Zinsperiode: Vierteljährlich; Renditeberechnung: Geometrische Rendite | 156.553,61 € | Not a standard convention (closest: Equivalent monthly rate, end of month, off by -54.77) |
| extraETF | E · Einzahlungsart: Vorschüssig; Zinsperiode: Halbjährlich; Renditeberechnung: Geometrische Rendite | 155.187,09 € | Not a standard convention (closest: Equivalent monthly rate, end of month, off by -1421.29) |
| extraETF | E · Einzahlungsart: Vorschüssig; Zinsperiode: Jährlich; Renditeberechnung: Geometrische Rendite | 152.602,00 € | Not a standard convention (closest: Equivalent monthly rate, end of month, off by -4006.38) |
| extraETF | E · Einzahlungsart: Nachschüssig; Zinsperiode: Monatlich; Renditeberechnung: Geometrische Rendite | 156.608,38 € | Equivalent monthly rate, end of month |
| extraETF | E · Einzahlungsart: Nachschüssig; Zinsperiode: Vierteljährlich; Renditeberechnung: Geometrische Rendite | 155.678,33 € | Not a standard convention (closest: Equivalent monthly rate, end of month, off by -930.05) |
| extraETF | E · Einzahlungsart: Nachschüssig; Zinsperiode: Halbjährlich; Renditeberechnung: Geometrische Rendite | 154.326,66 € | Not a standard convention (closest: Equivalent monthly rate, end of month, off by -2281.72) |
| extraETF | E · Einzahlungsart: Nachschüssig; Zinsperiode: Jährlich; Renditeberechnung: Geometrische Rendite | 151.769,75 € | Not a standard convention (closest: Equivalent monthly rate, end of month, off by -4838.63) |
| extraETF | E · Einzahlungsart: Vorschüssig; Zinsperiode: Monatlich; Renditeberechnung: Arithmetische Rendite | 162.959,42 € | Rate ÷ 12, start of month |
| extraETF | E · Einzahlungsart: Vorschüssig; Zinsperiode: Jährlich; Renditeberechnung: Arithmetische Rendite | 157.553,35 € | Interest credited yearly, simple interest within the year (start) |
| extraETF | E · Einzahlungsart: Nachschüssig; Zinsperiode: Monatlich; Renditeberechnung: Arithmetische Rendite | 162.014,34 € | Rate ÷ 12, end of month |
| extraETF | E · Einzahlungsart: Nachschüssig; Zinsperiode: Jährlich; Renditeberechnung: Arithmetische Rendite | 156.667,87 € | Interest credited yearly, simple interest within the year (end) |
| Frankfurter Sparkasse | E | ~157.494 Euro | Equivalent monthly rate, start of month |
| Invesco | E | € 162.959 | Rate ÷ 12, start of month |
Which convention to use
Use the equivalent monthly rate when the rate you have is a yearly return: a fund's past CAGR, an expected market return or an APY. Use the rate divided by 12 when it is a nominal rate compounded monthly, as on many loans and deposit accounts. Choose the deposit timing that matches when the money actually goes in. For Korean installment savings, the standard simple-interest formula is used by every bank tested.
CalcMyCompound's market pages follow each market's regulator or bank standard and let you switch convention where calculators disagree: SIP calculator (all three Indian conventions), 積立シミュレーション, Sparplanrechner, 적금 이자 계산기 and the compound interest calculator.
Method and limits
On 21 November 2026 (UTC) each calculator was opened in headless Chromium from a cloud server, consent banners were declined, the scenario was typed or set exactly, and the result was read twice after it updated. Every displayed value was then compared with closed-form results under each common convention and attributed to the one it matches within the calculator's display rounding (cents, whole units, 0.1 lakh or 0.1 万円). Screenshots of every result are retained in the evidence record.
Calculators change; these results describe the versions online on the test date. Values shown only in lakh or 万円 are rounded by the calculator. We tested the main published settings and each timing option offered, not every combination. Taxes and costs were switched off where the calculator allowed it. The study covers convention differences, not the quality of the advice or products on the tested sites.
Disclosure
CalcMyCompound, published by Kymata Labs LLC, offers its own calculators in these markets, so it competes with the sites tested. Kymata Labs has no commercial relationship with any tested site and received nothing for this study. Every calculator received the same scenarios; where our own pages appear, they were checked with the same closed-form references.
Data and citation
Every observation, with the calculator, URL, setting, displayed value, matched convention and test time, is available under CC BY 4.0: JSON · CSV. Please cite as: Kymata Labs (2026). Same Inputs, Different Answers: 29 Savings Calculators Tested. CalcMyCompound. https://www.calcmycompound.com/en/research/savings-calculator-study-2026/
Cite this page
- Permanent link
- https://www.calcmycompound.com/en/research/savings-calculator-study-2026/
- Last checked
- APA
- Kymata Labs. (2026, November 21). Same Inputs, Different Answers: 29 Savings Calculators Tested. CalcMyCompound. https://www.calcmycompound.com/en/research/savings-calculator-study-2026/
- MLA
- “Same Inputs, Different Answers: 29 Savings Calculators Tested.” CalcMyCompound, Kymata Labs, 21 Nov. 2026, https://www.calcmycompound.com/en/research/savings-calculator-study-2026/.